Skip to content

This site uses cookies to store information on your computer. Some are essential to make our site work; others help us improve the user experience. By using the site, you consent to the placement of these cookies. Read our privacy policy to learn more.

Close
AICPA-CIMA
  • AICPA & CIMA:
  • Home
  • CPE & Learning
  • My Account
Journal of Accountancy
  • TECH & AI
    • All articles
    • Artificial Intelligence (AI)
    • Microsoft Excel
    • Information Security & Privacy

    Latest Stories

    • Incorporating prompt engineering into the accounting curriculum
    • Create a dynamic to-do list with Excel’s checkboxes
    • Another way to manage authentication texts
  • TAX
    • All articles
    • Corporations
    • Employee benefits
    • Individuals
    • IRS procedure

    Latest Stories

    • Treasury posts preliminary list of jobs eligible for no tax on tips
    • Taxpayer’s circumstances do not warrant equitable tolling
    • When does debt become worthless?
  • PRACTICE MANAGEMENT
    • All articles
    • Diversity, equity & inclusion
    • Human capital
    • Firm operations
    • Practice growth & client service

    Latest Stories

    • Treasury posts preliminary list of jobs eligible for no tax on tips
    • California issues draft guidance for climate risk disclosure
    • Business outlook brightens somewhat despite trade, inflation concerns
  • FINANCIAL REPORTING
    • All articles
    • FASB reporting
    • IFRS
    • Private company reporting
    • SEC compliance and reporting

    Latest Stories

    • SEC accepting Professional Accounting Fellow applications
    • SEC names new chief accountant
    • SEC ends legal defense of its climate rules
  • AUDIT
    • All articles
    • Attestation
    • Audit
    • Compilation and review
    • Peer review
    • Quality Management

    Latest Stories

    • AICPA unveils new QM resources to help firms meet Dec. 15 deadline
    • 8 steps to build your firm’s quality management system on time
    • Auditing Standards Board proposes a new fraud standard
  • MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING
    • All articles
    • Business planning
    • Human resources
    • Risk management
    • Strategy

    Latest Stories

    • Business outlook brightens somewhat despite trade, inflation concerns
    • AICPA & CIMA Business Resilience Toolkit — levers for action
    • Economic pessimism grows, but CFOs have strategic responses
  • Home
  • News
  • Magazine
  • Podcast
  • Topics
Advertisement
  1. newsletter
  2. Extra Credit
Extra Credit Cover

Succeed at teaching no matter your temperament

You don’t have to be very outgoing to be an effective educator.

By Dawn Wotapka
June 9, 2020

Please note: This item is from our archives and was published in 2020. It is provided for historical reference. The content may be out of date and links may no longer function.

Related

May 12, 2020

Redesign your final exams to truly promote learning

April 14, 2020

An online pivot can be an opportunity

TOPICS

  • Accounting Education

College professors may be subject matter experts, but that does not mean that they’re necessarily good teachers. That’s a key point Jessamyn Neuhaus, Ph.D., makes in her book Geeky Pedagogy: A Guide for Intellectuals, Introverts, and Nerds Who Want to Be Effective Teachers (West Virginia University Press, 2019). The good news, she writes, is that anyone can become a better teacher by channeling their passion for their subject into proven teaching techniques.

We spoke with Neuhaus, a professor of U.S. history and popular culture at State University of New York at Plattsburgh, about the tough feedback that led to her book, myths about what makes someone a good teacher, and ways to inspire students.

Extra Credit: “Just because you know a lot about something doesn’t mean you can teach it.” Tell me where this brutal phrase came from and how it changed you.

Neuhaus: At the end of any class, most college instructors receive an anonymous student survey about it. The above quote was the first such comment I got back from a student about my very first college class. Brutal? Maybe a little. Accurate? Yes. I knew a ton about the subject I was teaching, but I didn’t know beans about how to clearly communicate and built rapport with students or to help novice learners utilize my subject to build skills. This comment forced me to start learning how to do those things.

Extra Credit: Your book isn’t really about geeky professors. It’s about how being invested in a subject can, ironically, make for boring instruction that doesn’t inspire students. How can it be true that someone who knows a topic so well can’t teach it? 

Neuhaus: Think of an Olympic medal-winning swimmer trying to show someone who’s afraid of water how to dog-paddle. Think about how far back into their memory the Olympian has to go to recall what it feels like to be learning how to implement those foundational skills needed to just stay afloat. Moreover, think about how differently these two people even perceive a swimming pool. To the Olympian, it’s an empowering place of achievement, where innumerable hours of passionate, hard work has made them extremely successful. To the nervous novice swimmer, it’s a scary, mysterious place of fear and danger. 

Experts like accountants have spent years accumulating very specific knowledge and applying that knowledge in real, measurable ways. They’ve chosen their field, drawn to it because it interested them and because they find personal and professional satisfaction using the skills and abilities it requires. Effective educators understand and acknowledge that we experts are very different from most of our students in this way. There are so many things we do easily, even automatically, that our students are just starting to learn how to do. That’s why we have to look to the scholarship of teaching and learning — the research and the proven best practices — to help us translate our own knowledge into things our students can do. (Neuhaus recommends resources on her website.)

Advertisement

Extra Credit: How can a professor realize if he or she is not inspiring students before the semester ends? 

Neuhaus: Two words: Formative feedback. That is to say, consistently and repeatedly asking for student feedback throughout the class and making adjustments in response to that feedback (and in light of pedagogical research about what works) during the class, instead of relying on one survey at the end of class when it’s too late to make any changes. Many college instructors are so invested in their subject matter, so intent on “getting through” the material, that they don’t want to stop and really assess if students are actually getting it or to take the time to really examine closely how students are responding to their pedagogical practices.

Extra Credit: You write about how teaching is a social craft. How can an introverted person be successful at it?

Neuhaus: What’s helped me the most is understanding how teaching and learning are built on a foundation of clear communication, rapport, and trust with students. That’s what enables me to push out of my comfort zone (being all alone with my lovely thoughts) and find ways to connect with students and create learning communities in my classes, because I know that if I want students to learn how to do things with my subject matter, I must attend to the social and emotional aspects of learning, not just the intellectual work. The science of learning and the brain shows this unequivocally.

But the good news is that there are myriad ways to build rapport with students and maintain positive interpersonal connections. We don’t have to try to be someone we’re not. We do have to communicate to students that we care about their learning and their success in our class and that we want to share our passion for accounting or literature or coding or philosophy or whatever it is we love with all our nerdy, dorky hearts. 

Extra Credit: So you don’t necessarily have to be extremely outgoing to be an effective teacher?

Neuhaus: I’d caution anyone who’s teaching anything to avoid the trap of the super-teacher stereotype. I mean a highly idealized, narrowly defined, and unrealistic image of what good teaching and learning looks like, i.e., a charismatic (usually a white cisgendered male) professor standing in a lecture hall expounding effortlessly while students magically, easily learn merely by being in his totally entertaining presence.

Advertisement

That’s not how teaching and learning work. Learning anything is hard and takes a really long time. Learning means making mistakes. It requires not only intellectual, but also emotional effort, and it takes a ton of practice. Helping students do this takes many forms and can look very different from class to class, instructor to instructor. Terms like “inspirational” can trigger the super-teacher fantasy ideal, which subsequently undermines instructors’ belief in their own unique abilities to help students learn. 

There’s one, and only one, nonnegotiable quality that every effective teacher must possess: the desire to be an effective teacher. Everything else — personality, pedagogical techniques, abilities, experiences — can vary widely, as long as someone is willing to always keep learning about effective teaching by studying the scholarship of teaching and learning, reflecting on their pedagogical missteps and successes, and seeking support for building their teaching skills.

— Dawn Wotapka is a Georgia-based freelance writer. To comment on this article or to suggest an idea for another article, contact senior editor Courtney Vien at Courtney.Vien@aicpa-cima.com.

Advertisement

latest news

September 4, 2025

Treasury posts preliminary list of jobs eligible for no tax on tips

September 4, 2025

California issues draft guidance for climate risk disclosure

September 4, 2025

Business outlook brightens somewhat despite trade, inflation concerns

September 3, 2025

New: Digital assets practice aid addresses auditing of lending, borrowing

August 29, 2025

Guidance on research or experimental expenditures under H.R. 1 issued

Advertisement

Most Read

The No. 1 risk to retirement – and one way to guard against it
Tax provisions in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act
Billy Long out as IRS commissioner after less than two months
Calculating AI’s impact on CPAs: New study quantifies time savings
AICPA unveils new QM resources to help firms meet Dec. 15 deadline
Advertisement

Podcast

September 4, 2025

Summing up economic sentiment and concerns about inflation and tariffs

August 29, 2025

Take a bold leap instead of a tentative step

August 28, 2025

Mark Koziel Q&A: Talent, sense of community, profession opportunities

Features

Calming nervous clients nearing retirement
Calming nervous clients nearing retirement

Calming nervous clients nearing retirement

7 retirement tips for small firm CPAs
7 retirement tips for small firm CPAs

7 retirement tips for small firm CPAs

Building a better CPA firm: Stepping up service offerings
Multi-colored plus signs

Building a better CPA firm: Stepping up service offerings

2025 tax software survey
Smiley, frowney, and neutral faces for Tax Software Survey.

2025 tax software survey

SPONSORED REPORT

Smart Strategies in Data Security and Risk Management

In an increasingly digital profession, data security has become one of the most critical challenges facing finance and accounting professionals today. Stay up to date with practical guidance to help you mitigate these risks and strengthen your security posture.

From The Tax Adviser

August 30, 2025

2025 tax software survey

August 30, 2025

Are you doing all you can to keep the cash method for your clients?

July 31, 2025

Current developments in S corporations

July 31, 2025

Paid student-athletes: Tax implications for universities and donors

MAGAZINE

September 2025

September 2025

September 2025
August 2025

August 2025

August 2025
July 2025

July 2025

July 2025
June 2025

June 2025

June 2025
May 2025

May 2025

May 2025
April 2025

April 2025

April 2025
March 2025

March 2025

March 2025
February 2025

February 2025

February 2025
January 2025

January 2025

January 2025
December 2024

December 2024

December 2024
November 2024

November 2024

November 2024
October 2024

October 2024

October 2024
view all

View All

http://JofA_Default_Mag_cover_small_official_blue

PUSH NOTIFICATIONS

Coming soon: Learn about important news

CPA LETTER DAILY EMAIL

CPA Letter Logo

Subscribe to the daily CPA Letter

Stay on top of the biggest news affecting the profession every business day. Follow this link to your marketing preferences on aicpa-cima.com to subscribe. If you don't already have an aicpa-cima.com account, create one for free and then navigate to your marketing preferences.

Connect

  • X Logo JofA on X
  • facebook JofA on Facebook

HOME

  • News
  • Monthly issues
  • Podcast
  • A&A Focus
  • PFP Digest
  • Academic Update
  • Topics
  • RSS feed rss feed
  • Site map

ABOUT

  • Contact us
  • Advertise
  • Submit an article
  • Editorial calendar
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms & conditions

SUBSCRIBE

  • Academic Update
  • CPE Express

AICPA & CIMA SITES

  • AICPA-CIMA.com
  • Global Engagement Center
  • Financial Management (FM)
  • The Tax Adviser
  • AICPA Insights
  • Global Career Hub
AICPA & CIMA

© 2025 Association of International Certified Professional Accountants. All rights reserved.

Reliable. Resourceful. Respected.