Skip to content

This site uses cookies to store information on your computer. Some are essential to make our site work; others help us improve the user experience. By using the site, you consent to the placement of these cookies. Read our privacy policy to learn more.

Close
AICPA-CIMA
  • AICPA & CIMA:
  • Home
  • CPE & Learning
  • My Account
Journal of Accountancy
  • TECH & AI
    • All articles
    • Artificial Intelligence (AI)
    • Microsoft Excel
    • Information Security & Privacy

    Latest Stories

    • Incorporating prompt engineering into the accounting curriculum
    • Create a dynamic to-do list with Excel’s checkboxes
    • Another way to manage authentication texts
  • TAX
    • All articles
    • Corporations
    • Employee benefits
    • Individuals
    • IRS procedure

    Latest Stories

    • Treasury posts preliminary list of jobs eligible for no tax on tips
    • Taxpayer’s circumstances do not warrant equitable tolling
    • When does debt become worthless?
  • PRACTICE MANAGEMENT
    • All articles
    • Diversity, equity & inclusion
    • Human capital
    • Firm operations
    • Practice growth & client service

    Latest Stories

    • Treasury posts preliminary list of jobs eligible for no tax on tips
    • California issues draft guidance for climate risk disclosure
    • Business outlook brightens somewhat despite trade, inflation concerns
  • FINANCIAL REPORTING
    • All articles
    • FASB reporting
    • IFRS
    • Private company reporting
    • SEC compliance and reporting

    Latest Stories

    • SEC accepting Professional Accounting Fellow applications
    • SEC names new chief accountant
    • SEC ends legal defense of its climate rules
  • AUDIT
    • All articles
    • Attestation
    • Audit
    • Compilation and review
    • Peer review
    • Quality Management

    Latest Stories

    • AICPA unveils new QM resources to help firms meet Dec. 15 deadline
    • 8 steps to build your firm’s quality management system on time
    • Auditing Standards Board proposes a new fraud standard
  • MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING
    • All articles
    • Business planning
    • Human resources
    • Risk management
    • Strategy

    Latest Stories

    • Business outlook brightens somewhat despite trade, inflation concerns
    • AICPA & CIMA Business Resilience Toolkit — levers for action
    • Economic pessimism grows, but CFOs have strategic responses
  • Home
  • News
  • Magazine
  • Podcast
  • Topics
Advertisement
  1. newsletter
  2. Extra Credit
Extra Credit Cover

How to identify your students’ stage of cognitive development

Keep these points in mind as you assess your students.

By Susan Wolcott, CPA, Ph.D.
October 8, 2019

Please note: This item is from our archives and was published in 2019. It is provided for historical reference. The content may be out of date and links may no longer function.

Related

September 10, 2019

How to help students who are ‘Perpetual Analyzers’

August 13, 2019

How to help students who are ‘Biased Jumpers’

July 16, 2019

How to help students who are ‘Confused Fact-Finders’

June 11, 2019

Guide students toward better critical thinking

TOPICS

  • Accounting Education

Editor’s note: This is the fifth in a series of articles to help you explore student abilities, and how critical thinking is taught and learned, to better enable you to help your students thrive in today’s complex business and accounting environment.

This series of articles has provided specific recommendations for helping students improve their critical thinking within accounting courses. In the introductory article, I described the three most common “stages” of critical thinking, and the next three articles provided learning ideas for those three stages.

This last article in the series addresses how to determine which stage of cognitive development your students have reached, and presents some of my observations and suggestions for teaching critical thinking.

Most college students are in stages 1 and 2

When you’re trying to determine what stages of cognitive development your students have reached, it’s helpful to have a starting point. A 1994 meta-analysis of data across many institutions and degree programs found the following average stages of cognitive development for undergraduate and graduate students:

Undergraduate first-year average: Stage 1.63

Undergraduate fourth-year average: Stage 1.99

Master’s/early doctoral average: Stage 2.62

Advertisement

(Note: These averages are based on data reported on page 161 by P.M. King and K.S. Kitchener, 1994. I converted reflective judgment stages 3, 4, and 5 in their model to Stages 1, 2, and 3 in my model.)

In general, the above data suggests that many students in introductory accounting courses are likely to operate at Stage 1 (“Confused Fact-Finder”), while the average for fourth-year undergraduate students is Stage 2 (“Biased Jumper”). In my accounting classrooms, I have found similar cognitive patterns, although the distribution varies across schools and programs. I have not observed any significant changes in the distributions during recent years.

How to gain information about your students’ stages of cognitive development

The second, third, and fourth articles in this series each provided indicators to help you recognize students who are operating at cognitive Stages 1, 2, and 3. In addition to those indicators, a quick way to gather information about student thinking is to give them five minutes during class to write a paragraph explaining why some aspect of the course involves uncertainty. Below are examples of possible questions:

  • Introductory financial accounting: Explain why even the manager might not know the actual amount of bad debts for the company.
  • Introductory management accounting: Explain possible reasons why managers might be unable to accurately estimate future costs.
  • Cost accounting: Identify and explain possible reasons why managers would be uncertain about the effects of a new performance measure on employee behavior.
  • Auditing: Identify and explain possible reasons why auditors might not discover evidence that an important internal control for an audit client is not always operating correctly.
  • Tax accounting: Identify and explain possible reasons why a tax client cannot be certain about future income tax rates.

Stage 1 (Confused Fact-Finder) students have very little to say in response to these types of questions, and they often make irrelevant statements. For example, they might recite definitions or technical knowledge instead of answering the question. Or they might state that the company needs to hire a better manager, who will know the amount of bad debts.

Although failure to recognize uncertainty is a key characteristic of Stage 1 thinking, I have found that answers to questions about uncertainty provide me with useful information about all students. Stage 2 (Biased Jumper) students identify at least some uncertainty but provide little explanation. Stage 3 (Perpetual Analyzer) students often provide very thorough discussions about the types and causes of uncertainty. You can quickly sort student papers into three “stacks” to gain an estimate of the number of students at Stages 1, 2, and 3.

Students might not be ‘at’ a stage

Developmental psychology research suggests that people do not necessarily operate at one cognitive stage and that development can be slow. Below I discuss two major implications for accounting educators.

First, students often exhibit inconsistent patterns of thinking while they are learning new skills. For example, a student at Stage 2 may begin to more thoroughly and objectively analyze information, suggesting they are moving toward Stage 3. The student’s critical thinking might seem to improve but later revert to Stage 2. I have found that student performance often drops during times of stress (such as a final exam) and when an assignment raises emotions (such as an ethics case). It is normal to observe development followed by regression. It might take students two academic years to develop stable Stage 3 skills.

Advertisement

Second, students’ levels of cognitive development might vary across subject matters based on preconceived ideas. For example, students might enter an introductory accounting classroom expecting to learn well-defined material with single correct answers. Students who operate at Stage 2 in another course might revert to Stage 1 in introductory accounting. More importantly, students who prefer single correct answers might choose accounting as a major if their introductory course is taught as subject matter that involves concrete answers.

Because development can take a long time and because perceptions of accounting as a subject where the answers are clear-cut can hinder development — and can attract misguided students to accounting —it is essential that critical-thinking development begin in introductory accounting courses.

In addition, faculty members need to remain patient as they help students develop critical thinking. Try not to become frustrated when students fail to quickly demonstrate and maintain new skills!

Don’t confuse clear communication with critical thinking

When I grade student papers, some students with strong communication skills initially seem to demonstrate strong critical thinking. But when I look more carefully, I discover that their analyses and conclusions are biased and that the paper displays skepticism only toward other viewpoints (i.e., Biased Jumper thinking). Other times, a student’s poor communication initially gives an impression of weak critical thinking — which turns out to be incorrect upon closer inspection. To minimize these types of assessment/grading errors, I first assess a student’s writing and then reread the paper to assess the critical-thinking skills.

A teacher’s journey

When I initially learned about cognitive development and its impact on student learning, I discovered that many seemingly odd student responses to coursework could be readily explained by their levels of cognitive development. I have improved my abilities as a teacher by paying close attention to student responses and by trying to understand why students respond the way they do. I encourage you to take this same journey.

Susan Wolcott, CPA, Ph.D., CMA, is a founder of WolcottLynch, which conducts research and develops educational resources for critical-thinking development. She has taught accounting courses at seven universities and is currently a visiting professor at the Indian School of Business. To comment on this article or to suggest an idea for another article, contact senior editor Courtney Vien at Courtney.Vien@aicpa-cima.com.

Advertisement

latest news

September 4, 2025

Treasury posts preliminary list of jobs eligible for no tax on tips

September 4, 2025

California issues draft guidance for climate risk disclosure

September 4, 2025

Business outlook brightens somewhat despite trade, inflation concerns

September 3, 2025

New: Digital assets practice aid addresses auditing of lending, borrowing

August 29, 2025

Guidance on research or experimental expenditures under H.R. 1 issued

Advertisement

Most Read

The No. 1 risk to retirement – and one way to guard against it
Tax provisions in the One Big Beautiful Bill Act
Billy Long out as IRS commissioner after less than two months
Calculating AI’s impact on CPAs: New study quantifies time savings
AICPA unveils new QM resources to help firms meet Dec. 15 deadline
Advertisement

Podcast

September 4, 2025

Summing up economic sentiment and concerns about inflation and tariffs

August 29, 2025

Take a bold leap instead of a tentative step

August 28, 2025

Mark Koziel Q&A: Talent, sense of community, profession opportunities

Features

Calming nervous clients nearing retirement
Calming nervous clients nearing retirement

Calming nervous clients nearing retirement

7 retirement tips for small firm CPAs
7 retirement tips for small firm CPAs

7 retirement tips for small firm CPAs

Building a better CPA firm: Stepping up service offerings
Multi-colored plus signs

Building a better CPA firm: Stepping up service offerings

2025 tax software survey
Smiley, frowney, and neutral faces for Tax Software Survey.

2025 tax software survey

SPONSORED REPORT

Smart Strategies in Data Security and Risk Management

In an increasingly digital profession, data security has become one of the most critical challenges facing finance and accounting professionals today. Stay up to date with practical guidance to help you mitigate these risks and strengthen your security posture.

From The Tax Adviser

August 30, 2025

2025 tax software survey

August 30, 2025

Are you doing all you can to keep the cash method for your clients?

July 31, 2025

Current developments in S corporations

July 31, 2025

Paid student-athletes: Tax implications for universities and donors

MAGAZINE

September 2025

September 2025

September 2025
August 2025

August 2025

August 2025
July 2025

July 2025

July 2025
June 2025

June 2025

June 2025
May 2025

May 2025

May 2025
April 2025

April 2025

April 2025
March 2025

March 2025

March 2025
February 2025

February 2025

February 2025
January 2025

January 2025

January 2025
December 2024

December 2024

December 2024
November 2024

November 2024

November 2024
October 2024

October 2024

October 2024
view all

View All

http://JofA_Default_Mag_cover_small_official_blue

PUSH NOTIFICATIONS

Coming soon: Learn about important news

CPA LETTER DAILY EMAIL

CPA Letter Logo

Subscribe to the daily CPA Letter

Stay on top of the biggest news affecting the profession every business day. Follow this link to your marketing preferences on aicpa-cima.com to subscribe. If you don't already have an aicpa-cima.com account, create one for free and then navigate to your marketing preferences.

Connect

  • X Logo JofA on X
  • facebook JofA on Facebook

HOME

  • News
  • Monthly issues
  • Podcast
  • A&A Focus
  • PFP Digest
  • Academic Update
  • Topics
  • RSS feed rss feed
  • Site map

ABOUT

  • Contact us
  • Advertise
  • Submit an article
  • Editorial calendar
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms & conditions

SUBSCRIBE

  • Academic Update
  • CPE Express

AICPA & CIMA SITES

  • AICPA-CIMA.com
  • Global Engagement Center
  • Financial Management (FM)
  • The Tax Adviser
  • AICPA Insights
  • Global Career Hub
AICPA & CIMA

© 2025 Association of International Certified Professional Accountants. All rights reserved.

Reliable. Resourceful. Respected.