Skip to content

This site uses cookies to store information on your computer. Some are essential to make our site work; others help us improve the user experience. By using the site, you consent to the placement of these cookies. Read our privacy policy to learn more.

Close
AICPA-CIMA
  • AICPA & CIMA:
  • Home
  • CPE & Learning
  • My Account
Journal of Accountancy
  • TECH & AI
    • All articles
    • Artificial Intelligence (AI)
    • Microsoft Excel
    • Information Security & Privacy

    Latest Stories

    • Incorporating prompt engineering into the accounting curriculum
    • Create a dynamic to-do list with Excel’s checkboxes
    • Another way to manage authentication texts
  • TAX
    • All articles
    • Corporations
    • Employee benefits
    • Individuals
    • IRS procedure

    Latest Stories

    • Paper tax refund checks on the way out as IRS shifts to electronic payments
    • IRS keeps per diem rates unchanged for business travel year starting Oct. 1
    • Details on IRS prop. regs. on tip income deduction
  • PRACTICE MANAGEMENT
    • All articles
    • Diversity, equity & inclusion
    • Human capital
    • Firm operations
    • Practice growth & client service

    Latest Stories

    • Paper tax refund checks on the way out as IRS shifts to electronic payments
    • Practice mobility update: New NASBA tool tracks changes for CPAs
    • IRS keeps per diem rates unchanged for business travel year starting Oct. 1
  • FINANCIAL REPORTING
    • All articles
    • FASB reporting
    • IFRS
    • Private company reporting
    • SEC compliance and reporting

    Latest Stories

    • SEC accepting Professional Accounting Fellow applications
    • SEC names new chief accountant
    • SEC ends legal defense of its climate rules
  • AUDIT
    • All articles
    • Attestation
    • Audit
    • Compilation and review
    • Peer review
    • Quality Management

    Latest Stories

    • AICPA unveils new QM resources to help firms meet Dec. 15 deadline
    • 8 steps to build your firm’s quality management system on time
    • Auditing Standards Board proposes a new fraud standard
  • MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING
    • All articles
    • Business planning
    • Human resources
    • Risk management
    • Strategy

    Latest Stories

    • Business outlook brightens somewhat despite trade, inflation concerns
    • AICPA & CIMA Business Resilience Toolkit — levers for action
    • Economic pessimism grows, but CFOs have strategic responses
  • Home
  • News
  • Magazine
  • Podcast
  • Topics
Advertisement
  1. newsletter
  2. Extra Credit
Extra Credit Cover

How to help students who are ‘Biased Jumpers’

Show students the importance of weighing other viewpoints.

By Susan Wolcott, CPA, Ph.D.
August 13, 2019

Please note: This item is from our archives and was published in 2019. It is provided for historical reference. The content may be out of date and links may no longer function.

Related

July 16, 2019

How to help students who are ‘Confused Fact-Finders’

June 11, 2019

Guide students toward better critical thinking

TOPICS

  • Accounting Education

Editor’s note: This is the third in a series of articles to help you explore student thinking, and how critical thinking is taught and learned, to better enable you to help your students thrive in today’s complex business and accounting environment. See the first article for an overview of critical thinking and the three most common patterns of thinking exhibited by college students, and the second for an in-depth look at the “Confused Fact-Finder” pattern.

Most students I have taught — in both undergraduate and masters-level accounting courses — have demonstrated the “Biased Jumper” pattern of thinking. My experience is consistent with cognitive development research in higher education. At this stage of development, students jump to a conclusion and then defend their position with personal biases and logic. Accordingly, I refer to this pattern of thinking as the “Biased Jumper” stage.

Biased Jumper thinking and how to recognize it

How can you recognize students who are operating at the Biased Jumper level of thinking? Below are common signs.


The student:

  • Jumps to a conclusion
  • Stacks up reasons and evidence quantitatively to support own view and ignores or inappropriately discounts contrary information
  • Equates unsupported personal opinion with other forms of evidence
  • Insists that all opinions are equally valid, but discounts other viable opinions
  • Views experts as being opinionated or as trying to subject others to their personal beliefs

Source: Wolcott, S.K. (January 26, 2006). Steps for Better Thinking Performance Patterns. Available at WolcottLynch.com. Based in part on information from Reflective Judgment Scoring Manual With Examples (1985/1996) by K.S. Kitchener and P.M. King. Grounded in dynamic skill theory (Fischer and Bidell, 1998; Fischer and Pruyne, 2002).


Because Biased Jumpers believe it is sufficient to simply stack up arguments to support their opinion — and because they believe that everyone acts the same way — they are highly resistant to more fully or objectively analyzing other viewpoints. These students are overconfident, believe it would be a waste of time to explore other viewpoints, and may become defensive if challenged or confronted with conflicting evidence.

How to help Biased Jumpers develop

Because students’ beliefs about knowledge drive their critical thinking approaches, our challenge as faculty members is to alter their underlying beliefs about how the world works. The most effective approach is to help these students move to the next-higher pattern of thinking, which I’ve nicknamed the “Perpetual Analyzer.” In this stage, students delay reaching a conclusion until they have fully and objectively analyzed multiple perspectives and evidence.

Advertisement
biased-jumper


(Note: These patterns are based on Stages 4 and 5 in the reflective judgment model developed by P.M. King and K.S. Kitchener. For details, see my freely available Faculty Handbook: Steps for Better Thinking. For a copy, send an email to swolcott@WolcottLynch.com.)

Teaching/learning recommendations

To move to the next stage, Biased Jumpers need to learn that good critical thinking means delaying conclusions until after they have objectively and thoroughly explored relevant information, including other viewpoints. Specifically, they must learn how to break down problems, to appreciate the need for multiple perspectives, to control for their own biases, and to qualitatively evaluate evidence and arguments. Here are some classroom activities that can foster each of these tasks:

  • Identify and control their own biases. Classroom discussions can help students recognize and learn to control their biases. Although undergraduate Biased Jumpers acknowledge the existence of other viewpoints, they are often surprised during class discussions to learn that multiple viewpoints exist within the classroom. Faculty can take advantage of student differences by conducting classroom discussions about the effects of preferences and preconceived notions when interpreting and using information. (Note: Students might be more willing to acknowledge and discuss “preferences” than “biases.”) You can also give students readings to help them learn about common biases and their negative impact on decision-making. Additionally, have students brainstorm ideas for identifying and controlling personal biases.
  • Provide arguments for and against alternatives. Students are usually taught to begin an essay with an introduction and thesis statement, and to begin a business memo with a statement of the problem and their conclusion. While this is a good way to organize and present the results of critical thinking, many students mistakenly believe that they must first choose their conclusion before analyzing information. They will probably also resist what they see as “wasting” their time exploring information that disagrees with their opinion. Thus, it is essential to require students to demonstrate more thorough analysis. One approach is to ask students to complete a table describing the pros and cons (or strengths and weaknesses, or costs and benefits) for each potentially viable alternative. Students might complete the table as homework, and then expand their tables during small-group and/or whole-class discussions. To increase student motivation to address both pros and cons, ensure that grading criteria require a balanced set of arguments.
  • Qualitatively evaluate evidence. Although Biased Jumpers recognize the existence of uncertainties, they often ignore those uncertainties when evaluating information. They tend to regard individual pieces of information in terms of whether it supports or does not support a viewpoint, and they ignore the quality of that information. To help students qualitatively evaluate information you can ask them to use a rating scale to evaluate the degree to which individual pieces of evidence support an argument as a homework task, and then reach an agreement on their rating with other students during small-group or whole-class discussions. You can also ask students to explain why some arguments/evidence are stronger than others.
  • Identify and analyze assumptions. Biased Jumpers often use assumptions, but they often fail to identify them or to evaluate their reasonableness. One way to help students is to ask them to define and explain the purpose of assumptions. Then help them learn to identify and apply criteria for evaluating the quality of assumptions. Note that it will be easier for students to initially identify and evaluate assumptions used by others. Then you can ask them to focus on their own assumptions.
  • Organize information into meaningful categories. As students develop stronger analysis skills, they will begin to consider a wider and richer set of information and have greater difficulty deciding how to organize it. You can help students improve both their analysis and organization skills by having them use concept mapping techniques. Consider having your students practice different methods for organizing information. Use of a critical thinking model can also help students organize their overall work into a statement of the problem, analyses, and conclusions.

Look for the next article in this series — which will address the “Perpetual Analyzer” stage of critical thinking — for more critical thinking teaching and learning ideas.

Susan Wolcott, CPA, CMA, Ph.D., is a founder of WolcottLynch, which conducts research and develops educational resources for critical thinking development. She has taught accounting courses at seven universities and is currently a visiting professor at the Indian School of Business. To comment on this article or to suggest an idea for another article, contact senior editor Courtney Vien at Courtney.Vien@aicpa-cima.com.

Advertisement

latest news

September 24, 2025

Paper tax refund checks on the way out as IRS shifts to electronic payments

September 24, 2025

Practice mobility update: New NASBA tool tracks changes for CPAs

September 23, 2025

IRS keeps per diem rates unchanged for business travel year starting Oct. 1

September 22, 2025

Managing teams, managing time: The importance of setting expectations

September 19, 2025

Details on IRS prop. regs. on tip income deduction

Advertisement

Most Read

MAP Survey finds CPA firm starting pay on the rise
IRS finalizes regulations for Roth catch-up contributions under SECURE 2.0
NASBA, AICPA release proposed revisions to CPE standards
Congress passes act allowing tax relief when a state declares disaster
IRS releases draft form for tip, overtime, car loan, and senior deductions
Advertisement

Podcast

September 25, 2025

Professional liability risks related to Form 1065, CPA firm acquisitions

September 18, 2025

‘We’re still the thinkers’ — a reminder for tax pros in the AI era

September 11, 2025

Strong storytelling helps speakers deliver ‘medicine’ without the aftertaste

Features

Calming nervous clients nearing retirement
Calming nervous clients nearing retirement

Calming nervous clients nearing retirement

7 retirement tips for small firm CPAs
7 retirement tips for small firm CPAs

7 retirement tips for small firm CPAs

Building a better CPA firm: Stepping up service offerings
Multi-colored plus signs

Building a better CPA firm: Stepping up service offerings

2025 tax software survey
Smiley, frowney, and neutral faces for Tax Software Survey.

2025 tax software survey

FROM THIS MONTH'S ISSUE

Flip out with the latest Tech Q&A

The September Technology Q&A column shows how to create dynamic to-do lists with Excel's checkboxes and also how to set up multifactor authentication texts that don't rely on phones. Flip through both items and view a video walkthrough in our digital format. 

From The Tax Adviser

August 30, 2025

2025 tax software survey

August 30, 2025

Are you doing all you can to keep the cash method for your clients?

July 31, 2025

Current developments in S corporations

July 31, 2025

Paid student-athletes: Tax implications for universities and donors

MAGAZINE

September 2025

September 2025

September 2025
August 2025

August 2025

August 2025
July 2025

July 2025

July 2025
June 2025

June 2025

June 2025
May 2025

May 2025

May 2025
April 2025

April 2025

April 2025
March 2025

March 2025

March 2025
February 2025

February 2025

February 2025
January 2025

January 2025

January 2025
December 2024

December 2024

December 2024
November 2024

November 2024

November 2024
October 2024

October 2024

October 2024
view all

View All

http://JofA_Default_Mag_cover_small_official_blue

PUSH NOTIFICATIONS

Coming soon: Learn about important news

CPA LETTER DAILY EMAIL

CPA Letter Logo

Subscribe to the daily CPA Letter

Stay on top of the biggest news affecting the profession every business day. Follow this link to your marketing preferences on aicpa-cima.com to subscribe. If you don't already have an aicpa-cima.com account, create one for free and then navigate to your marketing preferences.

Connect

  • X Logo JofA on X
  • facebook JofA on Facebook

HOME

  • News
  • Monthly issues
  • Podcast
  • A&A Focus
  • PFP Digest
  • Academic Update
  • Topics
  • RSS feed rss feed
  • Site map

ABOUT

  • Contact us
  • Advertise
  • Submit an article
  • Editorial calendar
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms & conditions

SUBSCRIBE

  • Academic Update
  • CPE Express

AICPA & CIMA SITES

  • AICPA-CIMA.com
  • Global Engagement Center
  • Financial Management (FM)
  • The Tax Adviser
  • AICPA Insights
  • Global Career Hub
AICPA & CIMA

© 2025 Association of International Certified Professional Accountants. All rights reserved.

Reliable. Resourceful. Respected.