Skip to content

This site uses cookies to store information on your computer. Some are essential to make our site work; others help us improve the user experience. By using the site, you consent to the placement of these cookies. Read our privacy policy to learn more.

Close
AICPA-CIMA
  • AICPA & CIMA:
  • Home
  • CPE & Learning
  • My Account
Journal of Accountancy
  • TECH & AI
    • All articles
    • Artificial Intelligence (AI)
    • Microsoft Excel
    • Information Security & Privacy

    Latest Stories

    • AI-driven spreadsheet tools — what CPAs need to know
    • Is spending on technology spinning out of control?
    • Using 3 Excel View tools to manage large spreadsheets
  • TAX
    • All articles
    • Corporations
    • Employee benefits
    • Individuals
    • IRS procedure

    Latest Stories

    • Social Security wage base and COLA announced for 2026
    • Congress passes bill requiring IRS to clarify math error notices
    • AICPA seeks IRS guidance on tip, overtime tax deductions for 2025
  • PRACTICE MANAGEMENT
    • All articles
    • Diversity, equity & inclusion
    • Human capital
    • Firm operations
    • Practice growth & client service

    Latest Stories

    • Social Security wage base and COLA announced for 2026
    • Navigating outside investors: Safeguarding ethics and independence in evolving practice structures
    • Congress passes bill requiring IRS to clarify math error notices
  • FINANCIAL REPORTING
    • All articles
    • FASB reporting
    • IFRS
    • Private company reporting
    • SEC compliance and reporting

    Latest Stories

    • SEC accepting Professional Accounting Fellow applications
    • SEC names new chief accountant
    • SEC ends legal defense of its climate rules
  • AUDIT
    • All articles
    • Attestation
    • Audit
    • Compilation and review
    • Peer review
    • Quality Management

    Latest Stories

    • Right-size your quality management documentation for SQMS No. 1
    • PCAOB publishes guidance related to Audit Evidence amendments
    • AICPA unveils new QM resources to help firms meet Dec. 15 deadline
  • MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING
    • All articles
    • Business planning
    • Human resources
    • Risk management
    • Strategy

    Latest Stories

    • Promotion opportunities abound for CFO hopefuls
    • Business outlook brightens somewhat despite trade, inflation concerns
    • AICPA & CIMA Business Resilience Toolkit — levers for action
  • Home
  • News
  • Magazine
  • Podcast
  • Topics
Advertisement
  1. newsletter
  2. Cpa Insider
CPA INSIDER

How to give constructive criticism that gets results

Show how small changes can be part of the big picture.

By Anslee Wolfe
February 26, 2018

Please note: This item is from our archives and was published in 2018. It is provided for historical reference. The content may be out of date and links may no longer function.

Related

November 1, 2017

Managing sideways

TOPICS

  • Professional Development
    • Communication
    • Career Development

Offering constructive criticism is an essential part of being a manager. Thoughtful feedback improves communication with staff members while encouraging them to grow.

When done effectively, constructive criticism has long-term benefits in the workplace, said Don Warrick, professor of business management and organization change at the University of Colorado at Colorado Springs.

“Concern for others and a desire to be helpful break down barriers to addressing issues and exploring solutions,” said Warrick, who has been a consultant and trainer for several Fortune 500 companies. “Make it possible, as much as you can, to create a climate that invites open and straightforward communication and problem-solving by all involved.”

But for many professionals, delivering constructive criticism can be daunting, said Loren Margolis, CEO and founder of Training & Leadership Success LLC, a global firm based in New York City that specializes in leadership training and executive coaching.

“Knowing all the benefits, why does the thought of giving feedback strike fear in new leaders? It’s likely because you’ve been on the receiving end of poorly delivered feedback yourself — and you remember how lousy and confused it made you feel,” she said.

One tactic that can help is reframing the way you view criticism. “Giving feedback, when it’s done well and thoughtfully, is really a gift,” said Kiyosha Baird, CPA, a senior finance manager with Microsoft who is based in Redmond, Washington. “You owe that to [your staff] so they can learn and grow. If you don’t give that feedback, that’s a disservice to the individual and the team.”

Here are some tips on how to give constructive criticism effectively:

Advertisement

Be mindful of your approach. Seeing criticism as part of a collaborative conversation can help you view it in a more positive light.

“It is very much a two-way conversation, but the tone needs to be inviting. Tone is vital,” said Baird, a 2017 AICPA Leadership Academy graduate.

To strike the proper tone, Margolis suggests opening with wording such as, “Let’s talk about the monthly financial reconciliation you started yesterday. There are two things I’d like you to change.”

Time it well. A mistake managers often make is letting too much time pass before addressing an issue. Give feedback immediately, said Margolis, who spent nearly a decade as a leadership coach and trainer for accounting and finance graduate students at Columbia Business School.

“When we get constructive criticism too long after the event, we do not see the reason for changing as clearly as we would if it were given right away,” she said. “We are human and so are our employees — we forget, or the situation becomes cloudy.”

Show the bigger picture. Employees are typically more receptive toward feedback when you call their attention to the benefits of addressing any trouble spots.

“What you want to focus on is going forward and how things will improve,” Baird said. “Let them know if they can bring this improvement about, this is how great it will be for the team.”

Advertisement

Be prepared to say why it is important for the employee to improve, Margolis said: Will changing their behavior impact team morale, for instance? Business success? Customer perceptions? Quality? Budget?

Be specific. To avoid confusion, describe the actual behavior you would like to see improved and share examples of how that might be achieved.

Early in Margolis’s career, a supervisor suggested she “act more like a leader.”

“I walked away from that conversation not only confused about what he meant — there are so many behaviors and qualities of a leader — but I also ended up acting in the very same way that I had before he gave me those unclear, unspecific directions, even though I very much wanted to take his advice,” Margolis said.

It would have been better, she said, if he had noted that he sensed leadership potential in her and would like her to show it more by taking specific actions such as leading meetings more often, coming in earlier than the rest of the team to serve as an example of dedication, and thinking of innovative ways to deepen customer experience.

Follow up. It’s important not only to give feedback but also to discuss ways you can support employees in meeting the expected outcomes. That may include any consequences.

“It’s really a full cycle of feedback,” Baird said. “It’s not just delivering the message, but making sure the message is heard and received.”

Advertisement

Anslee Wolfe is a freelance writer in Colorado Springs, Colo. To comment on this article or to suggest an idea for another article, contact Courtney Vien, a JofA senior editor.

Advertisement

latest news

October 24, 2025

Social Security wage base and COLA announced for 2026

October 22, 2025

Congress passes bill requiring IRS to clarify math error notices

October 22, 2025

AICPA seeks IRS guidance on tip, overtime tax deductions for 2025

October 21, 2025

IRS offers relief on car loan interest reporting under H.R. 1

October 20, 2025

STEM designation for accounting has strong support

Advertisement

Most Read

Why accountants need to master the art of reading the room
Using 3 Excel View tools to manage large spreadsheets
IRS furloughs nearly half its workers, closes most operations
Annual inflation adjustments announced for tax year 2026
IRS shutdown plan: Employees stay on the job for first 5 workdays
Advertisement

Podcast

October 23, 2025

Reflecting on AI’s rise in accounting, looking to what comes next

October 16, 2025

AI, succession, the talent pipeline, and defining ‘unapologetic’ ambition

October 8, 2025

Shutdown concerns, the quest for tax guidance, the future of IRS service

Features

AI-powered hacking in accounting: ‘No one is safe’
AI-powered hacking in accounting: ‘No one is safe’

AI-powered hacking in accounting: ‘No one is safe’

Building a better firm: How to pick the proper technology
Building a better firm: How to pick the proper technology

Building a better firm: How to pick the proper technology

Why accountants need to master the art of reading the room
Why accountants need to master the art of reading the room

Why accountants need to master the art of reading the room

How BI and analytics enhance management accountants’ partnering role
How BI and analytics enhance management accountants’ partnering role

How BI and analytics enhance management accountants’ partnering role

SPONSORED REPORT

Preparing clients for new provisions next tax season

Preparing clients for new provisions next tax season

As the 2025 filing season approaches, H.R. 1 introduces significant tax reforms that CPAs must be prepared to navigate. These legislative changes represent some of the most comprehensive tax updates in recent years, affecting both individual and corporate taxpayers. This report provides in-depth analysis and guidance on H.R. 1.

From The Tax Adviser

September 30, 2025

Current developments in taxation of individuals: Part 1

August 30, 2025

2025 tax software survey

August 30, 2025

Are you doing all you can to keep the cash method for your clients?

July 31, 2025

Current developments in S corporations

MAGAZINE

October 2025

October 2025

October 2025
September 2025

September 2025

September 2025
August 2025

August 2025

August 2025
July 2025

July 2025

July 2025
June 2025

June 2025

June 2025
May 2025

May 2025

May 2025
April 2025

April 2025

April 2025
March 2025

March 2025

March 2025
February 2025

February 2025

February 2025
January 2025

January 2025

January 2025
December 2024

December 2024

December 2024
November 2024

November 2024

November 2024
view all

View All

http://JofA_Default_Mag_cover_small_official_blue

PUSH NOTIFICATIONS

Learn about important news

This quick guide walks you through the process of enabling and troubleshooting push notifications from the JofA on your computer or phone.

CPA LETTER DAILY EMAIL

CPA Letter Logo

Subscribe to the daily CPA Letter

Stay on top of the biggest news affecting the profession every business day. Follow this link to your marketing preferences on aicpa-cima.com to subscribe. If you don't already have an aicpa-cima.com account, create one for free and then navigate to your marketing preferences.

Connect

  • X Logo JofA on X
  • facebook JofA on Facebook

HOME

  • News
  • Monthly issues
  • Podcast
  • A&A Focus
  • PFP Digest
  • Academic Update
  • Topics
  • RSS feed rss feed
  • Site map

ABOUT

  • Contact us
  • Advertise
  • Submit an article
  • Editorial calendar
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms & conditions

SUBSCRIBE

  • Academic Update
  • CPE Express

AICPA & CIMA SITES

  • AICPA-CIMA.com
  • Global Engagement Center
  • Financial Management (FM)
  • The Tax Adviser
  • AICPA Insights
  • Global Career Hub
AICPA & CIMA

© 2025 Association of International Certified Professional Accountants. All rights reserved.

Reliable. Resourceful. Respected.