Skip to content

This site uses cookies to store information on your computer. Some are essential to make our site work; others help us improve the user experience. By using the site, you consent to the placement of these cookies. Read our privacy policy to learn more.

Close
AICPA-CIMA
  • AICPA & CIMA:
  • Home
  • CPE & Learning
  • My Account
Journal of Accountancy
  • TECH & AI
    • All articles
    • Artificial Intelligence (AI)
    • Microsoft Excel
    • Information Security & Privacy

    Latest Stories

    • AI-driven spreadsheet tools — what CPAs need to know
    • Is spending on technology spinning out of control?
    • Using 3 Excel View tools to manage large spreadsheets
  • TAX
    • All articles
    • Corporations
    • Employee benefits
    • Individuals
    • IRS procedure

    Latest Stories

    • Job cuts mean strong 2025 tax season may be hard to repeat, IRS watchdog warns
    • IRS removes associated property rule in final interest capitalization regulations
    • Spouse is not entitled to sales proceeds in a judicial sale of taxpayer’s home
  • PRACTICE MANAGEMENT
    • All articles
    • Diversity, equity & inclusion
    • Human capital
    • Firm operations
    • Practice growth & client service

    Latest Stories

    • AI-driven spreadsheet tools — what CPAs need to know
    • Job cuts mean strong 2025 tax season may be hard to repeat, IRS watchdog warns
    • Is spending on technology spinning out of control?
  • FINANCIAL REPORTING
    • All articles
    • FASB reporting
    • IFRS
    • Private company reporting
    • SEC compliance and reporting

    Latest Stories

    • SEC accepting Professional Accounting Fellow applications
    • SEC names new chief accountant
    • SEC ends legal defense of its climate rules
  • AUDIT
    • All articles
    • Attestation
    • Audit
    • Compilation and review
    • Peer review
    • Quality Management

    Latest Stories

    • AICPA unveils new QM resources to help firms meet Dec. 15 deadline
    • 8 steps to build your firm’s quality management system on time
    • Auditing Standards Board proposes a new fraud standard
  • MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTING
    • All articles
    • Business planning
    • Human resources
    • Risk management
    • Strategy

    Latest Stories

    • Business outlook brightens somewhat despite trade, inflation concerns
    • AICPA & CIMA Business Resilience Toolkit — levers for action
    • Economic pessimism grows, but CFOs have strategic responses
  • Home
  • News
  • Magazine
  • Podcast
  • Topics
Advertisement
  1. newsletter
  2. Cpa Insider
CPA INSIDER

How to handle poor performers

Start by promoting the right people to be managers.

By Doug Blizzard
August 17, 2015

Please note: This item is from our archives and was published in 2015. It is provided for historical reference. The content may be out of date and links may no longer function.

Related

August 10, 2015

Be strategic when awarding raises and promotions

August 6, 2015

What do employees want?

TOPICS

  • Firm Practice Management
    • Human Capital

I obviously don’t work for your CPA firm, but my experience tells me there is a good chance that you have subpar performers who are draining its productivity, profit, and growth. I wish I was wrong—but I see it everywhere, every day, in every industry.

The hard truth is that subpar workers are actually a byproduct of subpar management. You can’t fix the problems with your workers until you address the deficiencies in your managers.

But first, let’s explore just why subpar performers are such a problem. Poor performance generally comes in three categories. Employees who:

  • Don’t know what to do. Many employees regularly wander around our workplaces not knowing what is expected of them. This can generally be solved by managers who provide clearer expectations. Most people will perform just fine when they know what to do.
  • Can’t do what you’re asking. Sometimes we can salvage this “can’t-do” category with training. Sometimes, though, training will not correct the performance and in those cases the employee should be transferred to an open job they can do—or they need to go work for someone else.
  • Won’t do what you’re asking. This is the most dangerous category. Employees who won’t do what you’re asking create tremendous problems in the workplace every day. Whether they vocalize their refusal or use more subtle activities, like slowing down, or overlooking things, there is only one solution for these people: They need to leave, and soon.

Subpar workers translate into missed deadlines, poor customer service, and sloppy processes. Moreover, top performers don’t appreciate having to do additional work to cover for their uninspired co-workers. Frustrated overworked top performers will either leave or will actually start to scale back their effort.

This is a particularly pertinent point for CPA firms, which now find themselves in something of a talent war for the best accountants. Firm leaders often look to pay and benefits as a way to attract and retain talent. While that’s part of the answer, people stay at their jobs for other reasons as well—and the quality of their direct manager is near the top of the list.

Why management sometimes takes a back seat

The art of management sometimes takes a back seat in professional service environments, in part because so many people are so highly educated. Firm leaders sometimes make the mistake of believing that because people are so accomplished, they don’t need a lot of “managing.”

Advertisement

But that’s a grave mistake. In a professional service firm, your people are the product you’re delivering to clients. So what kind of employees do you want interfacing with clients? You want ones that are motivated, productive, and see how they fit in the big picture, right?

Conversely, you don’t want an employee who does just enough to get by or one that is biding time until he or she can find another opportunity. And you certainly don’t want a deceitful employee.

The type of employee you have is directly related to the quality of management at your firm. And quality management starts with getting the right person in the supervisor’s chair.

The training part of management is easier than you might think. There are hundreds of good courses out there to train a manager to identify and address poor performance. However, we often promote the wrong people simply because they are technically proficient.

That approach can lead to your firm’s “losing” a great accountant in exchange for gaining a lousy manager. Think about the sports world. Most great coaches were average (or worse) players themselves. The sporting world has learned that playing and coaching are two totally different skill sets that need to be assessed and developed. Companies that lead every industry have also figured out that you need great coaches and great players and the former doesn’t always have to come from the latter. If that means redesigning compensation systems to reward technically proficient workers so that they don’t have to go into management to get a raise, so be it.

Hire slow and fire fast

Once you have the proper people in management roles, give them the support they need to address the problems caused by subpar workers. In some cases, training and mentoring will be enough. In others, your managers will have to replace subpar workers with new employees.

Advertisement

“Hire slow and fire fast,” are good words to live by for managers. Yet I frequently find companies actually do the opposite: They hire quickly and impulsively and then take forever to separate from the problem employee. Many performance problems are really hiring problems in disguise. So try taking more time assessing candidates. And once you know someone is a poor performer, address it quickly. Fairly and respectfully, yes, but quickly.

Who doesn’t get this right? Ask yourself that question the next time as a consumer you have a bad customer experience at the hands of a problem employee. Then, ask yourself if any of your clients have the same question when they work with your firm. Think about it.

Doug Blizzard is the vice president for membership for CAI, a nonprofit employers’ association handling HR, compliance, and people development.

Advertisement

latest news

October 2, 2025

Job cuts mean strong 2025 tax season may be hard to repeat, IRS watchdog warns

October 2, 2025

Is spending on technology spinning out of control?

October 1, 2025

IRS removes associated property rule in final interest capitalization regulations

September 30, 2025

IRS withdraws prop. regs. affecting corporate spinoff transactions

September 30, 2025

FASB update refines reporting scope for derivatives

Advertisement

Most Read

MAP Survey finds CPA firm starting pay on the rise
IRS finalizes regulations for Roth catch-up contributions under SECURE 2.0
NASBA, AICPA release proposed revisions to CPE standards
IRS releases draft form for tip, overtime, car loan, and senior deductions
IRS shutdown plan: Employees stay on the job for first 5 workdays
Advertisement

Podcast

October 2, 2025

Car talk: M&A, AI and EVs changing the dealership landscape

September 25, 2025

Professional liability risks related to Form 1065, CPA firm acquisitions

September 18, 2025

‘We’re still the thinkers’ — a reminder for tax pros in the AI era

Features

AI-powered hacking in accounting: ‘No one is safe’
AI-powered hacking in accounting: ‘No one is safe’

AI-powered hacking in accounting: ‘No one is safe’

Building a better firm: How to pick the proper technology
Building a better firm: How to pick the proper technology

Building a better firm: How to pick the proper technology

Why accountants need to master the art of reading the room
Why accountants need to master the art of reading the room

Why accountants need to master the art of reading the room

How BI and analytics enhance management accountants’ partnering role
How BI and analytics enhance management accountants’ partnering role

How BI and analytics enhance management accountants’ partnering role

SPONSORED REPORT

Preparing clients for new provisions next tax season

Preparing clients for new provisions next tax season

As the 2025 filing season approaches, H.R. 1 introduces significant tax reforms that CPAs must be prepared to navigate. These legislative changes represent some of the most comprehensive tax updates in recent years, affecting both individual and corporate taxpayers. This report provides in-depth analysis and guidance on H.R. 1.

From The Tax Adviser

September 30, 2025

Current developments in taxation of individuals: Part 1

August 30, 2025

2025 tax software survey

August 30, 2025

Are you doing all you can to keep the cash method for your clients?

July 31, 2025

Current developments in S corporations

MAGAZINE

October 2025

October 2025

October 2025
September 2025

September 2025

September 2025
August 2025

August 2025

August 2025
July 2025

July 2025

July 2025
June 2025

June 2025

June 2025
May 2025

May 2025

May 2025
April 2025

April 2025

April 2025
March 2025

March 2025

March 2025
February 2025

February 2025

February 2025
January 2025

January 2025

January 2025
December 2024

December 2024

December 2024
November 2024

November 2024

November 2024
view all

View All

http://JofA_Default_Mag_cover_small_official_blue

PUSH NOTIFICATIONS

Coming soon: Learn about important news

CPA LETTER DAILY EMAIL

CPA Letter Logo

Subscribe to the daily CPA Letter

Stay on top of the biggest news affecting the profession every business day. Follow this link to your marketing preferences on aicpa-cima.com to subscribe. If you don't already have an aicpa-cima.com account, create one for free and then navigate to your marketing preferences.

Connect

  • X Logo JofA on X
  • facebook JofA on Facebook

HOME

  • News
  • Monthly issues
  • Podcast
  • A&A Focus
  • PFP Digest
  • Academic Update
  • Topics
  • RSS feed rss feed
  • Site map

ABOUT

  • Contact us
  • Advertise
  • Submit an article
  • Editorial calendar
  • Privacy policy
  • Terms & conditions

SUBSCRIBE

  • Academic Update
  • CPE Express

AICPA & CIMA SITES

  • AICPA-CIMA.com
  • Global Engagement Center
  • Financial Management (FM)
  • The Tax Adviser
  • AICPA Insights
  • Global Career Hub
AICPA & CIMA

© 2025 Association of International Certified Professional Accountants. All rights reserved.

Reliable. Resourceful. Respected.