Social Security is an important piece of just about everyone’s retirement pie, but the rules for claiming it make it challenging to give clients the best advice. Unfortunately, there’s no one-size-fits-all approach, according to Ted Sarenski, CPA/PFS, president and CEO of Blue Ocean Strategic Capital LLC in Syracuse, N.Y. In a session Wednesday at the AICPA ENGAGE 2018 conference in Las Vegas, he outlined what practitioners need to know to advise their clients on the best strategies for their situation. We spoke with him about some of the factors CPAs need to consider when discussing Social Security with their clients.
What are the changes to Social Security for 2018 that CPAs need to be aware of?
Sarenski: One of the major ones to be aware of is that, between the ages 62 and 66, you’re limited as to how much you can earn. If you make more than $17,040, for every two dollars that you earn over that, you have to give back a dollar of your Social Security benefit. If you’re still working and earning $51,120 or more, it makes no sense to start Social Security at age 62 because you’ll be paying everything back.
Another important number is $128,400. That’s the maximum salary or self-employed income that you pay Social Security taxes on. Maybe you’re in a position where you can move money into this year or next year. If every year your income is similar, then you might move money into the current year and be over that maximum so that, over the two years, you’re not paying as much Social Security tax in total.
Do you have any other ideas for self-employed people?
Sarenski: A lot of self-employed people try to get their income as low as possible so they don’t pay a lot of income taxes. But they can hurt themselves by doing that. Your Social Security is based on your best 35 out of 40 years of earnings. So you might save some income taxes today, but you’re also minimizing the amount of Social Security benefit you’ll receive in the future.
How can people find the best balance of saving on their income taxes now and maximizing Social Security benefits?
Sarenski: There’s a calculator at the Social Security website that will give you many different types of calculations of benefits. Seeing a CPA would also be advisable in planning for retirement.
Social Security is important but shouldn’t be looked at in a vacuum. All other aspects of someone’s assets, sources of income, spending habits, and fixed and variable expenses need to be considered as well.
What is your best advice now on when clients should start claiming Social Security?
Sarenski: Everyone’s situation is unique. If you’re between 62 and 66, you’re very limited as to how much you can make and collect your full Social Security benefit. I rarely recommend [starting to claim benefits at age] 62 unless somebody just physically can’t keep working. You’ll receive 6% to 7% more a year by waiting until full retirement age [than you would had you taken benefits at 62]. The break-even point if you’re between 62 and 66 now — the age you need to reach to come out ahead — is roughly age 73 or age 74. That’s the age you will, over the course of your retirement, receive more total Social Security benefits by waiting to full retirement age to take them.
For most people, I would recommend full retirement age. Benefits continue to increase between full retirement age and age 70. For the difference between full retirement age and age 70, the break-even point is around age 82 or 83. So, if I think I’ll live long beyond that, then it becomes more of a lifestyle question. Would it be more important for me in my life to have a little extra money today to travel and do things I want to do?
However, if Social Security is a major part of what you are going to be living on, then it’s important to wait to age 70 to get the largest benefit.
What about spousal benefits?
Sarenski: If your spouse has very low earnings or no earnings, they’ll only get spousal benefits. Under the rules put in place in 2015, they can’t get a check now unless you are also taking a check. So, in those situations, it makes sense to start Social Security no later than full retirement age. Then your spouse will get half of your benefit plus you get your own benefit. If you wait to 70 to collect and your spouse is the same age, then he or she can’t get a spousal benefit until age 70 either.
Are there any changes for the future that we need to start thinking about now?
Sarenski: In 2034, the Social Security trust fund will run out of money. They’ll only be able to pay out about 79% of benefits based on the amount of money that comes in, so something needs to be done before that. 2034 is not that far away. The Y2K celebrations were 18 years ago, and that doesn’t seem that long ago.
We’re at the cusp of when people who will be retiring soon [those born in 1955 or later] will reach full retirement age at 66 and a few months, rather than 66. And those born 1960 and after will need to be 67 [to reach full retirement age]. Those rules were put in legislation that was done in 1984, and those rules are just being applied now.
How can CPAs get a sense of what might happen to Social Security in the future?
Sarenski: Since 2015, three separate bills have been introduced in Congress. These bills are the best guess as to the thinking process going on to fix Social Security. The proposed changes include increasing the wage base subject to Social Security tax; increasing the Social Security tax rate; decreasing benefits for high earners; raising the full retirement age; and changing the calculation methods for benefits, among other ideas.
What planning and saving strategies should people be thinking about instead of relying on Social Security?
Sarenski: Individuals need to be saving in their 401(k) if they have one available to them. If they don’t, they need to be contributing to IRA accounts. They also need to be saving outside of these tax-deferred vehicles to have enough so that they can live off the investments in retirement. A suggested savings rate for individuals in their 20s is 15% of their gross income. The older you get before you begin saving, the higher the percentage of your gross income that you need to save.
— Liz Farr, CPA, is a freelance writer based in Los Lunas, N.M. To comment on this article or to suggest an idea for another article, contact Ken Tysiac, a JofA editorial director, at Kenneth.Tysiac@aicpa-cima.com.