FinCEN: Commercial Real Estate Fraud Poses Risks to Economy

The Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) said reported incidences of suspicious activity in commercial real estate (CRE) financing almost tripled between 2007 and 2010. The analysis of suspicious activity reports (SARs) from depository institutions said a key concern in this area is the fact that an estimated $1.4 trillion in CRE loans will reach the end of their terms between 2010 and 2014.


The report, Commercial Real Estate Financing Fraud Suspicious Activity Reports by Depository Institutions , said that falling commercial rents and occupancy rates along with a rise in commercial loan defaults over the last several years have prompted growing concerns about the CRE market and its potential effects on the nation’s economy. The CRE market includes brokerage and lending services for the industrial, retail, office, hotel and multifamily housing sectors. SARs related to the CRE market involve a variety of transactions and activities related to the purchase and development of raw land as well as the acquisition, development, construction and improvement of commercial buildings.


FinCEN simultaneously released Advisory FIN-2011-A007, which provides examples of common commercial real estate fraud schemes, and suggests a key word for financial institutions to use when completing SARs involving potential commercial real estate fraud. The advisory lists several examples of common types of reported suspicious activity, including:


  • Misrepresentations. Subjects make false statements and/or submit falsified documents including rent rolls, tax documentation, appraisals, draw requests, lien waivers and financial statements to bolster loan applications. Subjects may also make fraudulent disbursement requests, including fraudulent invoices and receipts, to receive loan proceeds. This activity may occur across multiple banks using multiple accounts.
  • Misappropriation of funds. Borrowers misappropriate funds by diverting those funds to other projects for which loans or payments were not directed. This activity may be discovered during site inspections of customers’ property.
  • Bank insider collusion. Bank insiders facilitate loan approval processes and disbursement of funds for accomplices. Bank insiders’ suspicious client bases may move with them from employer to employer.
  • Flipping and straw-buyer schemes. Subjects may use straw buyers who “flip” the property to generate equity for another purchase, for profit, or to improve borrowers’ creditworthiness.
  • Collateral transfer. Borrowers sell collateral without disclosure to the lender or fail to forward proceeds of collateral sales to the lender, hide or convey the collateral to associates, or quit-claim deed the collateral to another entity. This may involve transferring ownership to family members or trust accounts, diverting funds for collateral improvements to other projects, or inflating collateral values, any of which would negatively affect the banks’ financial positions.
  • Advance fee schemes. Subjects engaging in advance fee schemes target borrowers, lenders and companies unable to obtain commercial real estate financing. These schemes may involve fraudulent business proposals and financial instruments.


FinCEN’s reports said that as the loans become due, analysts anticipate a delinquency rate of 10% because some borrowers will be unable to refinance due either to stricter underwriting standards or because the loan amounts outstanding exceed property values. The report said the valuation of the overall CRE market has fallen approximately 42% since it peaked in October 2007, with future fluctuation in CRE prices expected.


The analysis said 73% of the 2010 SARs originated from different financial institutions, indicating that CRE fraud affects a wide range of institutions of varying sizes and locations. Likewise, between 2007 and 2009, 71% of SARs originated from different financial institutions. For all these years, the top filer submitted 6% of SARs.


More from the JofA:


 Find us on Facebook  |   Follow us on Twitter  |   View JofA videos

Where to find May’s flipbook issue

The Journal of Accountancy is now completely digital. 





Leases standard: Tackling implementation — and beyond

The new accounting standard provides greater transparency but requires wide-ranging data gathering. Learn more by downloading this comprehensive report.