A Man of Principles

BY SAMUEL H. COPPOCK

Your interview with Robert Pozen (“Seeking Clarity ,” Oct. 07, page 30) was intriguing. My first question is: Who on the JofA staff interviewed him, and why was the byline not disclosed?

The most insightful question was, “How can more principles-based standards work in the U.S….?” His answer was, “No one wants to exercise judgment…it is less predictable how the courts would react to the judgment calls made by preparers or auditors….”

So my second question is this: When did “rules-based accounting” replace the preparer’s and the auditor’s judgment? What standard was that? Who decided this? Have courts and regulators thoroughly and completely discredited our judgment? If so, then why do states license us?

By way of reference, consider the article, “ It’s Time to Simplify Accounting Standards,” (March 99, page 65) by Dennis Beresford. A reprint of that may be timely. Today, international standards, a “principles-based” approach, are on the verge of overwhelming our arcane, brittle and increasingly obsolete U.S. GAAP.

I applaud the JofA for its interview with Pozen. Please continue to actively cover the continuing demise and collapse of “rules-based” accounting.

Samuel H. Coppock, CPA
Chandler, Ariz.

Editors’ note: In general, bylines in the JofA are reserved for authors. In the case of the interview with Mr. Pozen, the JofA solicited potential questions from a variety of technical experts. Several members of the JofA staff worked together to edit the questions and coordinate various elements of the interview.

Mr. Beresford’s article is available here.

SPONSORED REPORT

Tax reform complicates year-end tax planning

Get your clients ready for tax season with these year-end tax planning strategies, which address how to make the most of recent tax law changes, such as the new deduction for qualified business income and the cap on the deductibility of state and local taxes.

VIDEO

What RPA is and how it works

Robotic process automation is like an Excel macro that can work on multiple applications, says Danielle Supkis Cheek, CPA. RPA can complete routine, repetitive tasks such as data entry, freeing up employee time from lower-level chores.