Tax Software Makes the Grade

Vendors improve their technology support.

ax practitioners had reason to celebrate this year: Their software, as assessed in the annual Journal of Accountancy survey of tax-preparation software, performed better than it did last year. Adding to the joy, they’re no longer threatened with the possible need to convert to a new software package to replace orphan products that competitors acquired and then folded. With the number of vendors down to fewer than 20, from a high of 110 a decade ago, hardly any products seem susceptible to takeover.

When asked to rate their overall satisfaction with the 13 tax software products in the survey this year, the 3,156 AICPA Tax Section members who responded to the survey came up with a combined average score of 4.23 (out of a perfect 5.00), a significant gain from last year’s 4.03. In addition to the eight packages rated last year, three new products received the minimum required 10 responses from our CPA respondents. (For details about all the vendors in the survey, see exhibit 1 ; for a complete scorecard on the satisfaction grades, see exhibit 2 ; and for technical details about the products, see exhibit 6 .)

Tied for first place in the overall-satisfaction category, with ratings of 4.46, were Intuit’s highly popular Lacerte and the much smaller Dunphy System’s Tax Software for the Professional. Lacerte inched up from last year’s 4.32 rating; since Dunphy was not in last year’s survey, it has no year-ago rating. Tied for second place with 4.44 were Drake Software and Taxware System’s Taxware Tax Preparation; both are new to the survey this year.

The area that posted the biggest improvement was technical support, scoring 4.22, compared with a woeful 2.93 last year. At that time tax preparers complained bitterly that most vendors failed to meet their emergency needs: Vendor staffs were overwhelmed with questions and had too few experts available to respond with effective answers.

The support services of Drake and Creative Solutions’ UltraTax tied for first place with 4.47 each. UltraTax, which scored only 2.18 last year, clearly undertook a major overhaul of its tech-support operation for this year.

Also heartening to CPA firms, which are making more use of networks to link their offices’ computers, were improvements in the way their tax software operates on those networks. That average rating rose sharply to 4.30 this year from 4.02 a year ago.

While the immediate threat of continued vendor consolidation appears to have subsided, the market may not have reached a state of equilibrium with a settled number of vendors. The next few years may see yet another kind of transformation in the tax software market. As reliable high-speed—and eventually ultra-high-speed—Internet connections become widespread, vendors probably will begin redesigning the way they make their products available to customers. Currently most customers either download the software or are mailed a set of compact disks, with last-minute upgrades usually transmitted via the Internet. But reliable, fast Internet connections offer the possibility of speedier and more economical and reliable tax preparation. Instead of loading the software on their own computers and working on their local networks, most customers likely will access a central tax software utility.

A similar type of central utility service—this one for accounting—is slowly gaining ground, though obstacles remain. One big issue is whether the data, which are calculated and stored at the remote utility, are secure—not just from loss but also from hackers and industrial spies. The recent thefts of bank and credit card data undermine CPAs’ confidence in such a system. In time, however, it’s likely that security techniques will eliminate such dangers.

However, setting up a utility for tax preparation requires both sizable capital and new technical skills—an open invitation for new entries and partnerships in the existing software market. The bottom line: The next few years may bring significant changes in the tax software field, with smaller firms either partnering with high-tech organizations or being bought out by one of the better-capitalized tax software vendors.

Despite the lessening of the vendor consolidation threat, CPA firms continue to meander from one software product to another. Last year 11% said they were moving to another package because of dissatisfaction with their current product; this year nearly 16% reported such unhappiness and planned to order different software for 2006 (see exhibit 3 ). Some 3.8% of users cited price as the major reason to switch, while 2.2% cited poor customer support.

Meanwhile, the percentage of e-filings continues to rise. Accountants who responded to the survey e-filed an average 42.8% of their federal returns, up from 32.2% last year. State e-filing rose to 31.3%, up from 24.5% (see exhibit 4 ). In addition, 26.4% of respondents charged clients for e-filing services, and next year that percentage will rise to 33.8%. Exhibit 4 also shows the average percentage breakdown between tax preparations for businesses/nonprofits (64.9%) and for individuals (25.8%) for each brand of software.

A small percentage (5.7%) of survey respondents offered tax-refund advances as part of their service, about the same as last year ( exhibit 5 ). Exhibit 5 also provides a glimpse into which software products those firms that offer such advances use most frequently: Drake (21.2%), TaxSlayer Pro (20.0%), TaxWise (10.5%) and Taxware Tax Preparation (9.0%).

Only four products received a sufficient number of respondents’ answers for us to provide profile details on their tax-service customers. A CPA firm may find such information useful in determining whether a product is well-suited to its needs—in terms of the size of most of its customers, its ownership (sole practitioner, number of partners) and the type of clients it serves.

Lacerte: 34% of its customers are sole practitioners with an average staff of 1.3 professionals. About half have two to four partners, 10% have five to nine and 0.5% have between 20 and 49. Fourteen percent of its customers have multiple offices.

ProSeries: 44% of its customers are sole practitioners, with an average staff of 1.1 professionals. Nearly half have two to four partners and only 2% have more than 10.

ProSystem fx: 14% are sole practitioners with an average staff of two professionals; 29% have multiple offices and 15% are regional firms.

GoSystem: None of its customers is a sole practitioner; 64% have multiple offices. Most of its customers are regional, national and international firms.

UltraTax: 29% of its customers are sole practitioners with an average staff of 1.9 professionals; 20% have multiple offices with an average of 2.7 offices.

Use this guide to help you select the software product that most closely fits your needs. Be aware there is no such thing as a perfect product; what works for you may be a disaster for another tax preparer. Detailed product data and judgmental ratings from your peers, while valuable, are not the only—and surely not the best—way to make a software choice. The information is most useful for weeding out the products that are clearly unsuitable for you.

There is only one effective way to make a final decision—and that is to download an evaluation copy of the software and test-drive it with live data. While time-consuming, it tells you exactly what you need to know to make a final decision. We wish you success in locating the product that best serves your needs.

STANLEY ZAROWIN, a former JofA senior editor, is now a contributing editor to the magazine. His e-mail address is .


Get your clients ready for tax season

These year-end tax planning strategies address recent tax law changes enacted to help taxpayers deal with the pandemic, such as tax credits for sick leave and family leave and new rules for retirement plan distributions, as well as techniques for putting your clients in the best possible tax position.


Keeping you informed and prepared amid the coronavirus crisis

We’re gathering the latest news stories along with relevant columns, tips, podcasts, and videos on this page, along with curated items from our archives to help with uncertainty and disruption.