Recognize the Software, Recognize the Pitfalls

A CPA could write a book about the various implementation issues in SOP 97-2, Software Revenue Recognition (see "Software Revenue Recognition Updated," JofA, Nov.97, page 16). In fact, one did. Mary Pat McCarthy, national director of KPMG Peat Marwick's software and services practice, has coauthored Software Revenue Recognition: An Analysis of SOP 97-2 . She has examined possible areas of confusion in applying the standard, which brings order to an accounting area long marked by diverse practices. With the SOP already in effect, McCarthy spoke to the Journal about what companies need to know about software revenue recognition.

For example, paragraph 16 of the SOP discusses the use of written contracts as evidence of an arrangement between vendor and customer. "Companies have been asking some questions about how rigid the SOP is on this point—what if the customer signs the contract but the vendor doesn't get it until after the end of the reporting period? Paragraph 16 is clear: Even if the parties have an oral agreement, a written contract must be signed by both parties and received at the vendor before the reporting deadline. This assumes, of course, the vendor uses written contracts as a customary practice."

Another issue McCarthy sees as key involves specified upgrades. A vendor may agree to deliver current software by one date and to provide upgrades or enhancements later. In that case, the company should consider the upgrades as separate elements. "For example, many companies are promising future upgrades designed to be Y2K-compliant or able to handle European monetary unit transactions. These Y2K or EMU enhancements represent specified upgrades even if customers otherwise would be entitled to receive that software as part of maintenance."

A provision added to the SOP after the exposure period addresses, for example, steep discounts for postcontract customer support (PCS) contracts that take effect after the initial year. "It's a matter of judgment whether the discount is so steep that the vendor is actually providing an additional element." (That is, it's not an additional purchase but an additional element of the first one.) McCarthy sees vendors specifying a discount in advance to encourage customers to become long-term maintenance clients. "As a footnote in the SOP says, when a company offers significant discounts, the fee for the current arrangement, plus the anticipated renewal fee, needs to be allocated to all those elements. I think a lot of businesses will miss this in developing licensing agreements."

These are just a few of the changes. McCarthy advises a close examination of all the provisions of SOP 97-2. Institute members with questions on the SOP's guidance can call the Technical Information Hotline at 800-862-4272.

Financial Officers Rake It In

A survey of multi-billion-dollar U.S. companies showed that 1997 was a very good year for corporate financial executives, with double-digit compensation increases over 1996. Pearl Meyer & Partners, Inc., a New York City consulting company specializing in executive compensation strategy and programs, examined a group of service and industrial companies with average revenues of $19.4 billion. The survey revealed that, although financial managers are earning more than ever, components such as stock options and bonuses are becoming more important than base salary. Financial managers in a variety of senior positions saw their total pay packages achieve rapid growth.

However, the fixed portion of pay declined. Thirty years ago, salary constituted nearly all the compensation for these executives. It now accounts for less than half. The compensation package's nonsalary components increased very quickly while salary raises were modest. For example, controllers actually saw a small decrease in their salaries on average, even though they got large increases in the amount of stock options.

CFOs especially are seeing their fortunes rise and fall with those of their companies. Their salaries have become comparatively insignificant pieces of their compensation pie, as flexible rewards have risen:


©1998 AICPA


Supercharge your audit process with AI

Auditors today can employ AI to automate tedious tasks and gain far greater insights from their clients’ information. This free report lays out a five-step process for implementing AI and shows ways AI can add value to the auditing process.


Keeping you informed and prepared amid the coronavirus crisis

We’re gathering the latest news stories along with relevant columns, tips, podcasts, and videos on this page, along with curated items from our archives to help with uncertainty and disruption.