Index Funds Should Be Considered


Left out of “l0 Commandments of Mutual Fund Investing” (JofA, Aug.99, page 20) were what I believe to be the two most important pieces of advice:

  • In the long run, it is unlikely that an investor will be able to pick a mutual fund that beats the relevant market index. Despite big-name managers and lofty-sounding investment principles, a large majority of managed funds lose out to the unglamorous index funds. Attempting to beat an index fund has a small upside potential and a large downside one.
  • Investing in multiple mutual funds, as recommended in the article, lowers risk through diversification. It also virtually guarantees weaker overall performance than the relevant market index fund.

Neil D. Friedman, CPA
Boulder, Colorado

Author’s reply: The argument concerning index funds has some validity, but in only one sector of the equity market—large cap growth. Mutual funds that index the large cap growth sector have done well. However, this is not the case with large cap value, small cap growth, small cap value or international index mutual funds. If index funds are used for those categories, investors would be subject to average or below average performance.

Robert R. Thomas, CFA
Richard Musar, CPA
State College, Pennsylvania

SPONSORED REPORT

Revenue recognition: A complex effort

Implementing the new standard requires careful judgment. Learn how to make significant accounting judgments and document them and collaborate with peers for consistent application.

VIDEO

How to Excel pivot a general ledger

The general ledger is a vast historical data archive of your company's financial activities, including revenue, expenses, adjustments, and account balances. J. Carlton Collins, CPA, shows how to prepare data for, and mine data with, PivotTables.

QUIZ

News quiz: Taking an economic snapshot and looking to the future

Recent news included IRS actions that affect individuals and partnerships and a possibly influential move by a Big Four accounting firm.Take this short quiz to see how much you know about the news.