|
|
Carillon
|
eEnterprise
|
E by Epicor
|
MK Manufact'g
|
Enterprise IQ
|
Progression
|
ERP Plus
|
Scala 5.1
|
Solomon
|
Traverse
|
|
Evaluation of customer service and buyer support
|
Excellent
|
Good
|
Good
|
Good
|
Good
|
Good
|
Good
|
Average
|
Average
|
Good
|
|
Support fees
|
$250 per problem or up to $20,000 a year; two other support plans; maintenance is 15% of purchase price
|
21%35% of purchase price
|
18% of purchase price
|
Average $30,000 a year
|
14% of initial price for annual maintenance. From $750
$2,600 per user depending on modules
|
Average $3,400
$8,500, which represents 10%25% of retail price depending on support plan
|
11%15% of license fee depending on term of contract
|
20% of list price
|
Three tiers: ranges from 18%35% of list price
|
Per-minute charges
|
|
Scalability
|
Good
|
Good
|
Excellent
|
Good
|
Excellent
|
Good
|
Excellent
|
Fair
|
Excellent
|
Excellent
|
|
Average implementation time
|
3090 days
|
6090 days
|
36 months
|
610 months
|
36 months
|
4 months
|
3 months
|
26 months
|
2 weeks
|
2 weeks
|
|
Average cost
|
$20,000
$150,000
|
$50,000
$100,000
|
$50,000
$150,000
|
$150,000
|
$50,000
$80,000
|
$34,000
|
$125,000
|
Vendor will not disclose
|
$50,000
|
$1,300 per module
|
|
Maximum number of users
|
Unlimited
|
Unlimited
|
Unlimited
|
Unlimited
|
Unlimited
|
100+ in 5-user increments
|
Unlimited
|
Unlimited
|
Unlimited
|
Unlimited
|
|
Can all users be put under a flat fee?
|
Yes
|
No
|
No
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Yes, in packs of 5
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
Yes
|
|
Effectiveness of training programs
|
Average
|
Excellent
|
Average
|
Below average
|
Average
|
Good
|
Average
|
Below average
|
Average
|
Average
|
|
Training fees
|
$1,000
$1,500
per day
|
Varies by type
|
$195 and up per class
|
Average is $1,500
$2,000
per day
|
$300$450 per person; extra $1,200 per day for off-site service
|
$125$150 per hour
|
Training facility in Tampa, FL ($395 a day per person) or at your site (price negotiable)
|
$500 per day per person
|
$800
$3,500 per person
|
Vendor will not disclose
|
|
Industry-specific solutions available
|
Manufacturing, banking, distribution, construction, service, not-for-profit, government, real estate
|
Manufacturing, project
|
Manufacturing, software, professional services
|
None
|
Plastics
|
Not specified
|
SIC codes 35003800; medical and automotive
|
Pharmaceutical and hotel
|
Construction, contractors, professional service organizations, wholesale distributors, dispatch- oriented industries
|
Not specified
|
|
Microsoft and/or UNIX compatible?
|
Both
|
Microsoft
|
Microsoft
|
Both
|
Both
|
Microsoft and Novell
|
Microsoft, UNIX and Sybase
|
Pervasive Btrieve, Microsoft
|
Microsoft
|
Microsoft
|
|
Database compatibility
|
Oracle, Sybase, SQL Server
|
SQL
|
SQL
|
Ingres, Oracle, Bisam, Informix, SQL
|
Oracle
|
SQL, Pervasive Btrieve
|
SQL, Sybase
|
SQL
|
SQL Server 7.0 or 2000
|
SQL
|
|
Compatibility/partnerships with other software products
|
None
|
Siebel
|
No
|
Masterpiece, Computer Associates
|
ADP, FRx
|
Interact, Works.com
|
BEST!, ADP, Abra
|
No
|
Siebel Front Office: Silverbrook
|
Traverse eBusiness Solutions
|